HR · 25 July 2017

What to do if staff believe you’re paying men and women different amounts

BBC building
The BBC has come under fire for paying men and women different amounts
Publishing the BBC’s salary list has caused some employees to question their own firm’s pay arrangements. Here, advisory expert at law firm Peninsula, Kate Palmer, advises owners what to do once staff feel you’re paying men and women different amounts.

The BBC’s salary list has caused many people to question the rights and wrongs of paying high salaries to those who work at the corporation, but a wider debate has sprung up as the list seemingly shows the BBC paying men and women different amounts for doing similar roles.

When a debate like this arises, it can cause some employees to question the pay arrangements in their own companies, to check whether they are being paid less than people around them for the same job.

Employees may suspect that they are being paid less because of their gender. This is unlawful, as the Equality Act 2010 prohibits employers from paying men and women different amounts because of their sex.

Employees who can prove they are being paid less for doing like work work rated as equivalent or work of an equal value as the employee of the opposite gender, could bring an equal pay claim. Where the different salary is due to an internal policy, for example a policy that men will be promoted over women, the employee could also bring a sex discrimination claim.

Employers can defend against equal pay claims where they can prove they have an objective, material reason for the difference (which is not gender) and this is a proportionate means of achieving a legitimate aim. This could be the type of qualifications the employee has, the location the equivalent employee works in or market forces.

The financial risk of facing these claims is huge. Compensation for an equal pay claim will look to equalise salaries whereas compensation for sex discrimination is unlimited.

Employees may, however, simply feel that they are receiving less pay for doing the same work. Having discussions with the employee about why they are on their particular salary, what they can do to increase to the next level and setting realistic targets will help stop complaints turning in to bigger issues.

These discussions often take place at annual reviews or appraisal meetings. If the employee raises a concern outside of these meetings, it’s important to hold a discussion then and not wait until the next scheduled appraisal.

The requirement for larger companies to produce gender pay gap reports could see an increase in salary complaints. Although this is not a legal requirement, it is important for employers to make use of the voluntary option to provide additional contextual information.

This information can be used to explain any reason for paying men and women different amounts in a business, identify where results have been affected by, for example, a second job or a particular bonus, and set out the steps that the business will take in the future to tackle this.



Kate Palmer CIPD is the head of advisory at law firm Peninsula and is a member of its senior leadership team. She joined in 2009 having held a senior HR manager's role in another large company. With a specialist background in facilities management in the NHS, Kate offers a wealth of employment law experience. She's an expert negotiator - one notable case was with the NHS's trade unions over terms and conditions in the Agenda for Change pay system.

HR & Employment