Employment law

Can employers tell their employees to lose weight?

Kate Palmer | 17 January 2019 | 5 years ago

employee
Placing a requirement on staff to lose weight may only be advisable in specific circumstances
Employers need to evaluate if an individual’s weight impacts their ability to carry out day to day tasks associated with their job, writes Kate Palmer, associate director of advice at?Peninsula.

A recent news story has revealed that cabin crew members working for Pakistan International Airlines were told they needed to lose weight or face repercussions from their employer. This story raises the question of whether an employer can place a requirement on staff to maintain a certain weight or level of physical fitness.

Weight can be a sensitive issue in the workplace and employers should be careful when approaching this topic due to the risk of discrimination.

Although not specifically a protected characteristic in itself, a 2014 ruling by the European Court of Justice, in the case of Kaltoft v Municipality of Billund, found that obesity could qualify as a disability where it limits a person’s full and effective participation in professional life. This means that an individual recognised as obese would be protected under the Equality Act from any mistreatment at work.

Read more HR content:

Disabilities

An employee may be able to claim that a specific disability such as diabetes or hypothyroidism accounts for their weight. Therefore, it would be wise to steer clear of dismissing, disciplining or treating an employee any less favourably on account of their weight to reduce the chance of discrimination claims.

Given the risks, associated employers should really consider if an employee is required to be a certain weight to carry out their role effectively. If not, and it is purely for personal or aesthetic reasons, then it is likely to be considered inappropriate to ask staff to lose weight on this basis.

With this being said, there are of course exceptions and employers may require staff to maintain a certain level of fitness if they can justify that it is intrinsic to the job role. To assess this, employers need to evaluate if an individual’s weight impacts their ability to carry out day to day tasks associated with their job.

As an example, police officers are generally required to pass personal fitness tests as standard to prove they are able to meet the practicalities of the role. However, this is unlikely to be the case with regards to the cabin crew members, as it would be difficult to argue that their duties of tending to passengers during plane journeys will be adversely affected by their level of fitness.

Less intrusive approach

As an alternative, employers who are concerned about staff obesity levels and personal fitness should consider introducing less intrusive measures that promote a healthy lifestyle, such as providing free fruit or offering subsidised exercise classes. These initiatives are becoming increasingly common in the modern workplace with employers recognising this as an inexpensive and effective way of maintaining good health amongst their workforce.?

Ultimately, placing a requirement on staff to lose weight will not be advisable aside from in specific circumstances. Therefore, employers must seriously consider whether an individual’s weight significantly impacts their ability to perform their work duties before proceeding with any action.

Kate Palmer is associate director of advice at?Peninsula

Related Topics

Zero Hours Contracts Holiday Pay & Holiday Entitlement Explained
25 April 2022

Zero Hours Contracts Holiday Pay & Holiday Entitlement Explained

Read More →
What You Need to Consider When Changing An Employee’s Contract
4 March 2022

What You Need to Consider When Changing An Employee’s Contract

Read More →
Can You Dismiss A Pregnant Employee?
7 January 2022

Can You Dismiss A Pregnant Employee?

Read More →
How employment law affects an organisations HR and business policies and practices
21 July 2021

How employment law affects an organisations HR and business policies and practices

Read More →
The ultimate guide to holiday leave and pay in the UK
19 April 2021

The ultimate guide to holiday leave and pay in the UK

Read More →
Employing self-employed staff?
18 March 2021

Employing self-employed staff?

Read More →

If you enjoy reading our articles,
why not sign up for our newsletter?

We commit to just delivering high-quality material that is specially crafted for our audience.

Join Our Newsletter