Tax & admin · 12 September 2017

HMRC targets small businesses in tax avoidance crackdown

Unpaid business taxes
HMRC collected an additional £474m in corporation tax from investigations in small businesses

Small business owners have been urged to improve their record keeping, as a new report reveals HMRC has tightened its grip on tax avoidance by increasing investigations into the UK’s smallest firms.

Research from accounting group UHY Hacker Young revealed HMRC collected an additional £474m in corporation tax from small business owners as a result of investigations in the 2016/2017 tax year – a year-on-year increase of five per cent.

The figures arrive as the tax office comes under growing pressure to close Britan’s so-called “tax gap”. HMRC’s most recent official estimate, from October 2016, claimed £3.7bn of corporation tax was left uncollected in 2015.

UHY’s latest report claimed the tax office was “[turning the] spotlight onto small businesses”, having struggled to navigate the powerful in-house tax and accounts departments of the country’s largest firms.

Commenting on the report, Roy Maugham a tax partner at UHY, said HMRC’s singling out of smaller firms for investigation was “unfair”.

Maugham said the consequences of an investigation were most severe for owners of smaller companies, who may not have the resources needed to “bounce back”.

He added: “Small and medium sized businesses have not been top of HMRC’s agenda in the past, but that is now beginning to change as HMRC are under pressure to recover increasing amounts of tax.”

Maugham warned that HMRC was “not afraid to pull companies up” and urged owners to do everything they could do avoid small mistakes on their tax returns.

Sounding the alarm for founders, Phil Sayers, a director at accounting software provider Clear Books, said small business owners should be “concerned” by the report.

Explaining the approach being taken by HMRC, Sayers warned that small business owners “even accidental” understating their earnings could face severe penalties from the tax office.

He added: “HMRC can backtrack several years into their financial affairs, which can be both hugely time consuming and the penalties that could be imposed could be quite onerous. So for an SME that gets it wrong, even accidentally, it can cost them a lot of money.”

Sayers also highlighted the different approach taken by HMRC when targeting tax avoidance from smaller firms, after larger organisations have pushed back hard enough to negotiate a settlement deal with HMRC.

“But, if a small business receives a brown envelope from HMRC demanding tax and imposing a penalty, most don’t have that specialist knowledge and may not even be in a position to afford specialist third party services. Their initial reaction may be to get it off the books quickly and just pay it,” he explained.

Sayers warned that those running the smallest companies, undertaking all accounts themselves, could be most at risk.

“If you are the type of business that collects its receipts in a shoebox, for example, there is every possibility you are going to lose receipts along the way that then can’t be included in your accounts, thereby increasing the stated profit you have made.”

Small businesses have been told to prepare for a new HMRC online security measure

Sign up to our newsletter to get the latest from Business Advice.


 
TAGS:

ABOUT THE EXPERT

Simon Caldwell is a reporter for Business Advice. He has a BA in politics and communications from the University of Liverpool, and previously worked as a content editor in the ecommerce industry.

Q&A

If you’ve found the article above useful, but have a more detailed and bespoke question, then please feel free to submit a query to our expert. We at Business Advice will get in contact with them on your behalf and arrange for a personalised response. These questions and answers will then be collated on the site for any other readers who have similar queries.

Ask a question

From the top